I’m back with a new installment of picking a modern cast for Tales From The Crypt! This round, I chose one of the first episodes I ever watched, Lover Come Hack To Me. Lover Come Hack To Me follows a young newlywed who attempts to have the perfect honeymoon with her gold digging husband, but fate brings them to a large house with an eerie past. As always, I made my choices based on age, looks, and how I picture their overall performances. I hope you enjoy and let me know who you’d pick! (REMINDER: This is just hypothetical fun! I respect everyone mentioned and this series isn’t meant to tear anyone down or be disrespectful!!)

Peggy

Original Actress: Amanda Plummer (Pictured Top) – My Choice: Mia Goth (Pearl, Infinity Pool)

Charles

Original Actor: Stephen Shellen (Pictured Left) – My Choice: Richard Madden (1917, Rocketman)

Aunt Edith

Original Actress: Lisa Figus (Pictured Left) – Christine Baranski (Chicago, A Bad Moms Christmas)

Allen

Original Actor: Richard Eden (Pictured Top) – My Choice: Glen Powell (Scream Queens, Top Gun: Maverick)