I’m back with my next installment of Choosing A Modern Tales From The Crypt Cast! Today, I picked another one of my all-time favorite episodes, Strung Along! Strung Along follows Joseph Renfield, an aging puppeteer who gets the opportunity to appear on television again. However, as he’s preparing his new act, he begins to suspect that his young and beautiful wife is having an affair. As always, I made my choices based on age, looks, and how I picture their overall performances. I hope you enjoy and let me know who you’d cast! (REMINDER: this is just hypothetical fun!! I respect everyone mentioned and this series isn’t meant to tear anyone down or be disrespectful!!)

Joseph Renfield

Original Actor: Donald O’Connor (Pictured Top) – My Choice: Bill Fagerbakke (Spongebob Squarepants, Jennifer’s Body)

Ellen Renfield

Original Actress: Patricia Charbonneau (Pictured Top) – My Choice: Lucy Hale (Fantasy Island, Scream 4)

David

Original Actor: Zach Galligan (Pictured Top) – My Choice: Timothée Chalamet (Bones & All, Dune)