I’m back with my next installment of Choosing A Modern Tales From The Crypt Cast! Today, I picked another one of my favorites, Let The Punishment Fit The Crime. This episode centers around Geraldine Ferrett, an ambulance chasing lawyer who gets arrested in a horrible town that delivers the strictest punishments. As always, I made my choices based on age, looks, and how I picture their overall performances. I hope you enjoy and let me know who you’d cast! (REMINDER: this is just hypothetical fun! I respect everyone mentioned and this series isn’t meant to tear anyone down or be disrespectful!!)

Geraldine Ferrett

Original Actress: Catherine O’Hara (Pictured Left) – My Choice: Christina Ricci (Cursed, Black Snake Moan)

Austin Haggard

Original Actor: Peter MacNicol (Pictured Left) – My Choice: Elijah Wood (Cooties, The Faculty)

3 Judges

Original Actor: Joseph Maher (Pictured Top) – My Choice: Brendan Fraser (Brothers, Killers Of The Flower Moon)

Purdy Lee Dreyfus

Original Actor: Wesley Mann (Pictured Top) – My Choice: Eric André (Bad Trip, The Righteous Gemstones)