Welcome to Day 2 of Spooky Season!! I’m back with another installment of choosing a modern Tales From The Crypt Cast! Today, I picked one of my favorite episodes, My Brother’s Keeper, which follows two conjoined twins who are polar opposites. When one brother is desperate to be separate from the other, he hires a woman to woo him and convince him to get a very risky separation surgery. As always, I made my choices based on age, looks, and how I picture their overall performances. I hope you enjoy and let me know who you’d cast!! (REMINDER: This is just hypothetical fun!! I respect everyone mentioned and this series isn’t meant to tear anyone down or be disrespectful!!)

Frank Duran

Original Actor: Timothy Stack (Pictured Left) – My Choice: Lewis Pullman (Thunderbolts, Top Gun: Maverick)

Eddie Duran

Original Actor: Jonathan Stark (Pictured Left) – My Choice: Richard Harmon (Trick ‘R Treat, Final Destination: Bloodlines)

Marie

Original Actress: Jessica Harper (Pictured Left) – My Choice: Sarah Hyland (Modern Family)

Doctor Chencrow

Original Actor: Ron Orbach (Pictured Left) – My Choice: Jonas Bloquet (The Nun, The Nun II)

Dominatrix

Original Actress: Valerie Bickford (Pictured Left) – My Choice: Mekia Cox (The Rookie)