After finally finishing my posts for Spooky Season, I decided to throw on one of my all-time favorite shows, The Office! I figured now would be a good time for another installment of things The Office characters realized after watching the documentary. In this hypothetical, everything we’ve seen in the show was in the documentary and nothing was cut out. Also in this hypothetical, everyone who appeared in at least one scene in the show watched the documentary. I’m now including moments that were in the Superfan Episodes for a little extra fun. I hope you enjoy!! (SPOILER ALERT!!!)

The office realized Angela (Angela Kinsey) just let Andy (Ed Helms) float away to sabotage him.

Phyllis (Phyllis Smith) realized everyone was suddenly talking to her because they wanted free hot chocolate.

Katy (Amy Adams) realized Jim (John Krasinki) dumped her out of the blue because he was in love with Pam (Jenna Fischer).

Dwight (Rainn Wilson) realized the “C.I.A.” sending him on missions and telling him to destroy his phone were actually Jim and Pam.

A.J. (Rob Huebel) realized that Michael (Steve Carell) threw away his gift to Holly (Amy Ryan) and she lied to him about it.

Gabe (Zach Woods) realized that Pam and Oscar (Oscar Nuñez) were helping Erin (Ellie Kemper) cheat at Scrabble.

Andy realized that Dwight tricked Angela into marrying him while they were engaged.

Michael realized that Ryan (B.J. Novak) put Aspirin in his pudding.

Dwight realized Jim and Pam actually didn’t do anything to his wallet.

Toby (Paul Lieberstein) realized that Michael broke his racket to make a toilet invention.